Smart Computing ® Smart Computing ®
Top Subscribe Today | Contact Us | Register Now   
middle
Home | Tech Support | Q&A Board | Article Search | Subscribe & Shop   


Productive Gains Email This
Print This
View My Personal Library

Reviews
May 2006 • Vol.17 Issue 5
Page(s) 20-22 in print issue
Add To My Personal Library

Productive Gains
Office Suites For Less Than $100
Jump to first occurrence of: [STAROFFICE] [8]

When it comes to office suites, many users assume they have only one option: to spend a lot of money. A retail copy of Microsoft Office Standard edition costs $399. Its most visible competitorsCorel WordPerfect Office and Lotus SmartSuitestart at nearly $300 each. Even the upgrade editions of these suites cost $100 or more.

However, alternatives exist. Off-brand office suites, such as the ones profiled here, offer a wide range of features at a modest price. We advise budget-minded home and small-office computer users to consider these packages the next time they go shopping for productivity software.

602PC SUITE 4.1

602PC SUITE is software with a past. It was developed in 1989 by a company that originated as a computer club in communist Czechoslovakia. (The 602 refers to the club’s government licensing number.) After giving the suite a once-over in the present, we think it also has a future.

We had a good experience with 602PC SUITE. The download was quick, installation was a breeze, and registration no more of a hassle than Microsoft’s product activation process. Best of all, the learning curve for each component was minimal. Like the other off-brand office suites included in this roundup, the one from Software602 looks and acts a lot like Microsoft Office. Users who know anything about Word and Excel will quickly feel at home. The suite’s menus and toolbars come loaded with familiar commands and identifiable icons, for instance, and the program’s various components support all of the popular file formats for effortless sharing of files and documents.

Of course, significant differences exist between 602PC SUITE and its American competition. For one thing, this office suite consists of only four components: 602Text for word processing, 602Tab for building spreadsheets, 602Photo for editing digital images, and 602Album for organizing digital images. And each component comes up short on extended functionality. 602Text boasts a multilanguage spellchecker and a MagicText feature for creating word art, for instance, but lacks support for programmable macro commands. Likewise, 602Tab can interface with ODBC (Open Database Connectivity)-compliant databases but cannot do pivot tables or error checks.

But not all of the differences are negative. The Photo and Album components are nice extras, even if they do little more than provide basic image editing and organizing capabilities. The Read tool does an admirable job of converting alphanumeric characters to audio track in both 602Tab and 602Text. It correctly read “MB” as “megabyte,” for example, and translated “gen. practice” as “general practice.” We also appreciated the Export To PDF function, which converts any 602PC file to the PDF (Portable Document Format) file format. Microsoft Office doesn’t do that. Not yet, anyway.

Finally, support options are quite good. Users can find answers using the downloadable users manual, online knowledge base, or interactive support forums. Email and phone support is available at a rate of $49.95 and $59.95, respectively.

Ability Office Professional 4

Ability Office has been around in one form or other for more than 20 years. And while it may have an established record in its native England, the office suite remains a relative unknown in the United States. The full-featured suite delivers six components in one package. There’s the expected spreadsheet and text editor (known as Spreadsheet and Write, respectively), along with a database, presentation application, drawing program, and image editor. Users also have the option of buying components individually or in other combinations. That’s a big plus for users with specific needs.

However, we got off to a bumpy start with Ability. The product installs directly from the Web by default, which would be quite convenient if not for the network disruptions that interrupted the installation and forced us to restart the download from the beginning. Things got a bit confusing when it came to product registration, too. No instructions were provided, and we were prompted to enter the 18-character registration code each time we opened a component for the first time.

Once the suite was up and running, however, our experience improved dramatically. The text editor and spreadsheet closely model themselves after Microsoft Office. In fact, users can configure the programs to mimic their preferred version of Office: Office 2003, Office XP, or Office 2000. We chose 2003 and were impressed by the similarities. Spreadsheet and Write also boast several advanced features, including support for macros and mail merge. Ability’s other components offer baseline functionality but, as expected, lack the extended features found in their name-brand counterparts.

Each application supports output to PDF, and usability was never an issue. We liked the self-help wizards in Database and especially appreciated the well-equipped Photopaint Studio, which supports layers, 48-bit color, and a MagicWand tool for easy selection of like-colored objects. We had no problem importing existing files into the suite’s various components, although we remain cognizant of the fact that importing complex documents into theseor any other non-Microsoftapplications could present the occasional difficulty.






May 2006
Smart Choice
StarOffice 8

StarOffice 8

For nearly two decades, Sun has viewed Microsoft as its archrival. The Santa Clara, Calif.,-based company has proved a worthy competitor, especially in the enterprise marketplace. But it has failed to earn significant name recognition among home and small-office computer users. That may change. StarOffice 8, Sun’s latest alternative to Microsoft Office, delivers big-brand functionality at an off-brand price.

Following a quick installation and an effortless registration process, we began to explore the office suite. It features five components: Writer, a text editor; Calc, a spreadsheet; Base, a database; Impress, a presentation application; and Draw, a vector-graphics drawing program. What really makes StarOffice stand out, however, is that each componentnot just the text editor and spreadsheetcomes packed with Microsoft-caliber features. It supports macros and mail merge, for instance, as well as XML (Extensible Markup Language) forms and digital signatures. It allows users to export documents in PDFs, provides several self-help wizards for creating databases, and offers countless options for customizing presentations. No, StarOffice doesn’t have an image editor or contacts manager. But what can a user expect for less than $100? Certainly not extras.

Except that StarOffice has those, too. Registered users get three free phone or email support incidents in their first 60 days of use, a perk that is virtually unheard of these days. Each license is good for five installations, meaning users can put StarOffice on a desktop, a laptop, a second desktop, and still install it on the next two computers they buy. And users who aren’t sure whether they would like StarOffice have 90yes, 90days to try it free. Unless a user has a compelling loyalty to another office suite, we suggest taking advantage of that free trial.

ThinkFree Office 3

ThinkFree Office did not make much of a first impression. Besides the fact that its name is misleading (the suite is not freeware) and its installation inconvenient (who wants to download a 70.7MB setup file?), the open-source Java-based productivity suite has little to offer as a desktop application. It includes only three programs: Write, a text editor; Calc, a spreadsheet; and Show, a presentation application. Each program offers only the expected functions, such as a spellchecker and the ability to save documents as PDF files. Don’t bother looking for advanced features such as support for macros or the ability to include audio and video content in multimedia presentations. They aren’t there.

But then we encountered its online component, ThinkFree Office Online. This Web-based counterpart to the desktop productivity suite provides users with 30MB of free online file storage, as well as the ability to create, edit, and save text documents, spreadsheets, and presentations through a typical Web browser. Best of all, it’s free. (ThinkFree Office Online was in beta format when this review was written. The final release was expected to come online in March 2006.)

We found ThinkFree Office Online to be easy to use, and functionality seemed consistent with its desktop counterpart. We could insert locally stored clip art into the Web-based documents, for instance, and were able to save our files in multiple formats, including PDF. The service had some significant problems, though. Most notably, access was hit-or-miss. We received numerous errors while attempting to log in and open documents. Moreover, performance was relatively slow at times, even with a broadband Internet connection. Perhaps these issues will be addressed before the online editions are finalized and released. In any case, ThinkFree Office Online appears to have lots of potential, especially for users who frequently access their files on public computers. The bottom line: Skip the desktop edition and go straight for the Web.

Beyond Redmond

Quality productivity software is readily available for much less than the price of Microsoft Office or its name-brand competitors. The big question is whether the pricealbeit a low oneis worth it.

We think it is. Usability is certainly not a concern as the off-brand suites all do a marvelous job at mimicking Microsoft software. Functionality isn’t much of an issue either, as the off-brand suites will satisfy the needs of most home and small-office users. It really comes down to whether the user needs to share files with others. The porting of files between productivity suites always carries the potential for lost formatting and missing data. Users who frequently swap documents, spreadsheets, presentations, and databases with co-workers or clients should be aware of this.

Nevertheless, quality off-brand office suites are out there. And without a doubt, StarOffice 8 is the best. At less than a quarter of the price of Microsoft Office, the package is definitely worth serious consideration for anyone who prefers cash in hand to a popular brand.

by Jeff Dodd


BUYING TIPS

When considering off-brand software, always take advantage of any available free trial period. A low price proves expensive if the program conflicts with the rest of the system or fails to perform as expected.

Before investing in productivity software, users should consider what they really need. There’s no reason to order a six-piece suite when all a user needs is a spreadsheet and text editor. Ability offers the best deals for building an a la carte suite.


View the graphics that accompany this article.
(NOTE: These pages are PDF (Portable Document Format) files. You will need Adobe Acrobat to view these pages. Download Adobe Acrobat Reader)


 User Reviews Be the first to write a review of this product  





Want more information about a topic you found of interest while reading this article? Type a word or phrase that identifies the topic and click "Search" to find relevant articles from within our editorial database.

Enter A Subject (key words or a phrase):
ALL Words (‘digital’ AND ‘photography’)
ANY Words (‘digital’ OR ‘photography’)
Exact Match ('digital photography'- all words MUST appear together)





Home     Copyright & Legal Information     Privacy Policy     Site Map     Contact Us

Copyright © 2009 Sandhills Publishing Company U.S.A. All rights reserved.